Palestine

‘Truth under the rubble’: UN Special Rapporteur says Israel’s assault on the media has facilitated genocide

UN Special Rapporteur Francesca Albanese says in a report about the media and Palestine that “the destruction of truth has become integral to the destruction of a people”.

The report, entitled ‘Truth under the rubble: media in the time of genocide’, has just been publicly launched.

Albanese, who is the UN Special Rapporteur on the Occupied Palestinian Territories, cites what she calls “three interconnected patterns”:

  • the elimination of Palestinian media workers – through killing, maiming, arbitrary detention, torture, intimidation and the systematic labelling of them as “terrorists” – to suppress the documentation of crimes;
  • the construction of an information regime in Israel through media restrictions, censorship, propaganda, hate speech, genocidal incitement and denial; and
  • the role of influential international media and digital platforms in marginalising Palestinian voices and reproducing Israeli narratives, normalising legal distortions, which ultimately legitimised atrocities.

She says these practices have not merely accompanied the genocide committed by Israel, but have facilitated its commission and obstructed accountability.

“Viewed together, these practices constitute an assault on truth that is intrinsic to the genocidal violence they are intended to conceal,” Albanese writes.

“The elimination of witnesses, the suppression of freedom of expression and the abandonment of fundamental journalistic ethics may amount, in many ways, to ‘mediacide’: the systematic destruction of the media’s public function.”

Since October 2023, Israeli forces have killed nearly 300 journalists and wounded more than 400, Albanese says in her new report.

“While some were killed in indiscriminate attacks on civilian areas, around 70 were killed as reprisal for their work. Many were wearing press vests and helmets, carrying equipment or in marked vehicles and tents, which, instead of enabling the Israeli army to identify and protect media workers, facilitated their targeting.”

Only three months after October 7, 2023, the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR) said: “Gaza has seemingly become the deadliest place for journalists – and their families – in the world”.

Albanese states: “The destruction of more than 150 journalists’ homes since October 2023 signals intent to persecute the media sector.”

“Journalists have struggled to rent homes or offices in Gaza due to landlords’ fear that they would be targeted. Palestinian photojournalist Fatma Hassouna was killed alongside five family members on 16 April 2025 when precision-guided munitions struck their apartment at night, one day after her documentary on life during the genocide was selected for screening at the Cannes Film Festival.”

Albanese writes about the “particularly heinous warfare methods” used to murder journalists, including “double-tap” strikes.

“In August 2025, Israeli forces struck a balcony at Nasser Hospital where journalists routinely used to work, killing 22 people. The first strike killed Hussam Al-Masri, a Reuters cameraman; the second killed four more journalists who had rushed to the scene, alongside health and rescue workers. Israeli forces stated that they had targeted a ‘Hamas camera’, subsequently identified as Reuters’,” she states

Attacks continued beyond the October 2025 so-called ceasefire, Albanese adds. “On 21 January 2026, an Israeli air strike killed three Palestinian journalists driving to a displacement camp. On 8 April 2026, in one of multiple drone attacks, the Israeli army killed Al‑Jazeera journalist Mohammed Washah while he was driving his car. Israel justified these killings by alleging Hamas affiliation.”

On October27, 2023, Israel told Reuters and Agence France Press that it could not guarantee their journalists’ safety.

Since October 2023, 240 cases of Israel using live ammunition against media crews have been recorded. Reuters stopped sharing journalists’ locations with Israeli forces, fearing that such information could facilitate attacks. Many Palestinian journalists have received threatening calls, including death threats, ordering them to stop reporting.

Journalists’ families targeted

Journalists have limited their contact with their families following calls threatening to kill family members as punishment for their reporting, Albanese says.

She says evidence indicates that Israeli forces have deliberately targeted some journalists’ families.

Albanese cites the case of Al-Jazeera Arabic’s Gaza bureau chief, Wael Al‑Dahdouh. On October 25, 2023, an Israeli air strike on Nuseirat camp killed Al‑Dahdouh’s wife, his 15-year-old son, his seven-year-old daughter, and his one-year-old grandson.

Two months later, Al-Dahdouh and his colleague, Samer Abu Daqqa, were severely injured in an attack. After Israeli forces blocked the passage of ambulances, Mr. Daqqa bled to death.

On January 7, 2024, Al-Dahdouh’s eldest son, Hamza, also an Al‑Jazeera journalist, was killed along with a colleague in an air strike.

Smear campaigns

Albanese notes that military attacks on journalists have systematically been accompanied by smear campaigns portraying them as legitimate military objectives.

“In October 2023, the Israeli military reportedly established a special unit, the ‘legitimization cell’, which has systematically recast Gaza-based journalists as Hamas operatives,” she writes.

“These narratives intimidate journalists and establish a pretext before attacks, then retrospectively legitimize killings, ascribing responsibility to Palestinian armed groups by distorting international humanitarian law. The systemic justification of these attacks evidences an intent to target protected media workers.”

Attacks in the West Bank

In her new report, Albanese also writes about attacks on journalists in the West Bank.

“Over the past two years, journalists have also faced systematic attacks in the West Bank, including East Jerusalem, in the context of escalating settler terror and military operations, with 139 documented settler attacks on the press,” she writes.

“International visibility is far from a deterrent. For instance, in March 2025, weeks after winning an Oscar for the documentary No Other Land, journalist and co‑director Hamdan Ballal was attacked in his home in Masafer Yatta by Israeli settlers, then detained overnight by the army.

“Also in 2025, German Deutsche Welle crews were attacked in separate incidents with stones by settlers and with tear gas by the Israeli army, and Palestinian Reuters photographer Raneen Sawafta was attacked by settlers while covering the olive harvest, despite wearing press identifiers.”

Detentions

Since October 2023, Israel has detained more than 100 Palestinian journalists and media workers and about 30 are still incarcerated.

The new report states: “While numerous journalists have been arbitrarily detained following mass round-ups, several have been deliberately singled out …

“Released journalists describe enduring physical assaults; sexual violence, including rape; forced stress positions; sensory deprivation; inadequate food; and medical neglect. While Palestinian detainees are routinely subject to torture, journalists endure unique forms of intimidating interrogation as they are presumed to be ‘Hamas agents’ …

“Detained journalists have been threatened with renewed targeting if they continue reporting after release.”

Destruction of infrastructure

Albanese notes that, by October 2025, Israel had destroyed 150 media offices and institutions had been destroyed, including news agency headquarters, broadcast towers, and radio stations.

“In Gaza, Israel has completely destroyed 81 per cent and partially damaged 12 per cent of information and communications infrastructure, such as mobile towers, fibre optic cables and data centres,” she writes.

Albanese concludes: “Since October 2023, Israel has deployed every means at its disposal to silence Palestinian journalism, creating conditions in which independent reporting has become nearly impossible.

“Read in the context of the broader campaign against the Palestinian people, the scale and intensity of this assault reveal a deliberate effort not only to conceal mass atrocities, but also to erode the very possibility of documenting them.”

Media bias, and manipulation of communication

Albanese states in the new report: “The genocide has exposed long-standing ideological biases in media coverage of Palestine/Israel, including across Western traditional media and major digital platforms.

“It has exposed a system that determines whose voices are heard and whose suffering is recognised. These attempts to influence opinions through content curation, amplification and other forms of distortion have serious consequences for the human rights of the Palestinian people and those who defend their rights.”

Writing about the role of international media and digital platforms, she says that Palestinians have been dehumanised, legitimate criticism of Israel has been suppressed, and legal realities have been ignored or recast “to obscure or legitimise conduct amounting to genocide”.

Writing about Israel’s manipulation of online communication, Albanese notes that the Israeli prime minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, has described social media as an important “weapon”.

She cites the Israeli-directed ‘Project Esther’, a 2025 campaign that targeted United States audiences to suppress pro-Palestine mobilisation.

Albanese says that content analysis demonstrates that Western media rely heavily on Israeli sources, with Israeli officials and pressure groups enjoying privileged access to media decision makers, including at the British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC).

Internal editorial guidelines show how such influence translates into practice, she says.

“The BBC style guide, for example, omits Gaza from the occupied territory and specifies the Israeli Government’s ‘preferred’ description of the West Bank and Gaza as ‘disputed’ territories, without indicating that this is contrary to international law,” the new report states.

The report adds that New York Times guidance “similarly advises caution regarding the use of terms such as ‘genocide’, ‘ethnic cleansing’ and ‘occupied territory’, instructing journalists to use ‘Palestine’ only ‘in very rare cases’.”

“Such editorial imperatives have marginalized historical context and legal frameworks that are essential to understanding the root causes of this renewed violence. Media references to the Nakbah, to decades of occupation and related brutalities, to the illegality and continued settlement expansion and to the 19-year blockade of Gaza are absent or minimized, with 7 October 2023 presented as the origin of hostilities,” the report adds.

Damaging narratives

“Some of the most damaging narratives of the conflict – including allegations that Hamas had beheaded babies on 7 October, operated command centres beneath hospitals and had systematically infiltrated UNRWA and that Palestinian journalists killed by Israel were “terrorists” – were widely reported without verification.”

Albanese reports that, between October 2023 and August 2025, The New York Times referred to “human shields” used by Hamas 176 times and the BBC referred to them 81 times.

“Systematic references to ‘Hamas-run hospitals’ and ‘hospital shields’ and the unverified claims that Hamas operates from hospitals and other civilian sites have lent credibility to narratives that supposedly legitimize attacks on protected medical facilities,” the report states.

“This framing is particularly significant because the allegation that Hamas systematically used civilians as human shields is one of the Israeli Government’s principal legal justifications for its genocidal campaign in Gaza, including before the International Court of Justice.”

Albanese notes that findings by the United Nations, including in the International Court of Justice proceedings, and by human rights organisations, including on the question of genocide, have often been underreported or presented as disputed.

“In more than 100 documented instances, BBC presenters dismissed assertions that Israel was committing genocide, while Israeli leaders’ genocidal statements went unmentioned,” she notes.

The unequal attribution of responsibility is matched by an unequal distribution of empathy, Albanese adds.

“Studies demonstrate that Israeli suffering is narrated in detail and endowed with emotional and moral significance; Palestinian suffering is rendered partial, abstract or incidental.

“Thus, although Palestinian children accounted for approximately 99.7 per cent of child fatalities, they appeared in just over half of the personalized CNN reports on child victims.

“Across two sampling periods, The New York Times mentioned sexual violence against Israelis 76 times, but only four times in relation to Palestinians, despite substantial evidence of its widespread use against them.

“Even the moral vocabulary is unevenly allocated. Terms such as ‘barbaric’ are overwhelmingly reserved for violence against Israelis; at the German broadcaster ZDF, 90.7 per cent of uses have referred to Israeli victims, while the term has never been applied to attacks on Palestinians.”

Albanese notes that Western journalists who depart from the dominant narrative have faced pressure, disciplinary measures, reassignment, or dismissal.

She cites the case of Antoinette Lattouf, who was unlawfully dismissed by the Australian Broadcasting Corporation after reposting a Human Rights Watch report on starvation in Gaza.

“The publicly funded broadcaster spent more than $1.7 million of taxpayers’ money defending the dismissal, before the Federal Court of Australia found it unlawful and noted that senior management had acted to ‘appease the pro-Israel lobbyists’, Albanese writes.

“At BBC Arabic, journalists have been disciplined without any demonstration that editorial policies had been breached, which has even reportedly prompted the resignation of a senior journalist.

“Public events have been altered and documentaries withdrawn, including the BBC film on Gaza health workers and the broadcast of Wajib by ARD [in Germany]. Increasingly, reliance on human rights findings, criticism of Israeli State policies or solidarity with Palestinians have themselves been treated as suspect, collapsed into allegations of antisemitism.”

In an interview with broadcaster Samira Mohyeddin, Albanese said: “What I think is necessary, and this is what I have recommended, is to set up a mechanism to gather and preserve evidence of of the crimes that have been committed, including against journalists.

“It could be the commission on the protection of journalists. It could be the United Nations. It could be a hybrid system. It could be civil society-led. But there is a need to push Israel to stop attacking the information environment …”

This, Albanese said, includes freeing detained journalists, revealing the fate and whereabouts of the disappeared, letting the Red Cross see the detainees, letting foreign media and monitors enter Gaza, and Israel repealing its censorship laws and outlet bans. This, she said, was something that the United Nations should lead.

Israeli pushback

The pro-Israel NGO UN Watch said Albanese’s report substituted “selective evidence, unsupported inferences and distorted legal analysis for rigorous fact-finding”.

It said; “Far from exposing an ‘assault on truth’, it perpetuates one – under the imprimatur of the United Nations.”

In a mocking declaration, Israel’s permanent representative to the United Nations, Danny Danon, said Albanese should resign. He accused her of promoted Hamas ideology “by turning a blind eye to its atrocities and activities”.

Israeli media quoted a spokesperson for The New York Times as saying that, in her report, Albanese had made baseless, misleading and biased allegations about the newspaper’s coverage.

The spokesperson is quoted as saying that Albanese “offers no proof” for her assertion that Israeli officials and pressure groups influenced editorial guidance and that her statements about the newspaper’s coverage of sexual assault ignored the newspaper’s “repeated investigations on sexual violence against Palestinians”.

 

DONATE TO CHANGING TIMES VIA SIMPLE PAYMENTS

1= 5 euro, x 2 = 10 euro, X 3 =15 euro, etc.

€5.00